-
Can there ever be an online masterpiece?
One of the SXSW sessions I attended today was the Ze Frank session on the ‘creative lifestyle’. I found it a bit pointless, really. It appeared to be a love-in between Frank and a room full of his fans. But it did get me thinking about art and the internet.
The examples of Frank’s work left me unimpressed. I find them whimsical, disposable and inconsequential. I can see how they would provide some moments of entertainment, but this isn’t what I’m interested in. As I get older, I find myself more and more interested in identifying things that I can safely ignore and getting rid of them for good. My goal is to spend an extremely high percentage of my time on what I would like to call masterpieces.
I realise that this puts me in a minority, but it’s something I’d like to explore here for a little while. Please understand that I’m not opposed to entertainment; it’s just something I’m not interested in. No pejorative judgement is implied if you like entertainment. Read full post
-
Conflict resolution (or How to Deal with Bastards)
One of the SXSW sessions I went to yesterday dealt with the problems that arise when folks you work with are tricky, incompetent or just a bit of a pain in the backside. Whether it’s partners, clients or colleagues, at some point difficult situations inevitably arise and people don’t always play nice.
At this point I should probably caveat this post with the genuine declaration that no-one I work with is an a*shole. I’m pretty lucky in that respect.
Nevertheless, there was talk about the ways in which we can resolve conflict, bring people back on side and generally push the politics to one side to make sure that the project doesn’t suffer. Here are some of the pointers the panel shared with us:
1. Make sure expectations are set with partners at the beginning, and keep it unemotional when discussing falling short of them. Keep communication open and frequent, and if expectations are unclear on either side, sort it out as early as possible. This goes as much for our expectations of our clients as it does for their expectations of us.
2. If people are behaving badly on a project, they’re probably not doing it deliberately. Most likely, they’re just incompetent. Deal with it and, if possible (e.g. if it’s a third party partnership) try not to partner with them in future.
3. Don’t get into the bullsh*t of competitiveness and brinkmanship with colleagues - trust your work, stay cool, take the higher road. You’re not at school anymore, and no-one’s going to give you a medal for winning the playground brawl.
4. Turn the spotlight onto them: “If you were in my situation, how would you handle this? What would you do?” – make the bastard stand in your shoes. Seeing the other person’s point of view and asking for their suggestions can help find a solution.
5. Don’t be susceptible to bad vibes. As one of the panellists told his son: “Sad people like to make other people sad.” Or as we say in the UK, “Don’t let the buggers get you down…”
6. TIPS: Timely, Impact, Private, Specific
If someone’s being a bastard, follow ‘TIPS’. Deal with the issue in a timely manner; share the impact of what that person’s bastardly behaviour is having on the business (effect on the bottom line, negative influence on morale); speak privately with the bastard – don’t publicly humiliate them; be specific about the issue.
7. Be gracious, respectful and rise above the rudeness. One of the panellists had a great story about her time at Halliburton as General Counsel – she happens to be black. So, she was due to have a meeting with a group of people she’d never met and one of the guys in the meeting, assuming as a black woman that she must be in the service industry, asked her to get him a coffee. Without demur, she went and got him one, got herself one and then sat down at the meeting. He looked at her with incredulity – what the hell was this server doing sitting down?
Then the Chair walked in and suggested everyone introduce themselves. The ’server’ started by explaining that she was there as General Counsel to lend legal advice. The guy blushed crimson. She winked at him; that was all. He knew what he’d done, and that was shame enough. He’s now one of her greatest supporters and they have a good working relationship, all because she didn’t call him out. Smart.
8. Unless you’re in the military or prison service, remember that you can always walk away if it’s not working. This one really resonates with me. At Made by Many, we talk a lot about what makes for a successful project and are very careful about the jobs that we select. Our key criteria are: will we have fun doing it? will it make us famous/win an award? will it make us rich? will we learn in the process?
If a project doesn’t satisfy at least two, and preferably three or all of these criteria, then we don’t take the job.
One of the biggest keys to a successful project in our business is choosing the right kind of client. And as the panel said, if you make a bad choice and discover down the line that it’s just not working: have the courage to walk away. Otherwise, it drags everyone down, the project suffers and the end product is mediocre. No one’s happy.
Don’t be afraid to break up with them: “It’s not you, it’s me…It’s just not working anymore. We can still be friends. I just don’t feel that way about you anymore.” Sorry, getting a bit carried away with the therapy there. I blame the US capacity for ’sharing’, it’s rubbing off on me here in Austin.
The Chair said he’d buy everyone a beer if the panel didn’t come up with 8 ways to deal with a bastard. They just made it – lucky for him – there must’ve been 1500 people in the room. That’s a lot of Lone Star.
-
South by round up Day 1
How quickly can I fire off a blog post?Bag a waste of time. RecyclingPassion vs processExploring AustinSitting in a talkMxM homepageOur home pageThe reaction to our Twitter home page take over has been overwhelmingly positive. Thanks everyone for their feedback and comments. It was really fun working on it and seeing it in use in real time has sparked off lots of ideas about how we could use something similar as our permanent home page once we’re back home. Somehow we need to find a way of showing our social presence and network on the web, whilst combining the conversations around us.My favourite tweet about our home page?<they look beat up>Ah, our avatars. Always a source of amusement (or horror) when a new set arrive from our amazing illustrator (Paul Davis). I’ve always felt that their style reflects the Made by Many way – sketching and creating things being a big part of who we are and how we work. However, to clarify, in real life none of have fascinating skin conditions (@saradotdub), badger strips down out forehead (@bobbyc) or bolts sticking out of our neck (@malbonster).The SXSW experienceAfter registration at 11 yesterday I spent the entire day with a goodie bag slung over my shoulder, just like many attendee. I think the first thing we all did was sit down and throw stuff away:<silverlight>After getting rid of so much junk I was still left with a heavy bag of newspapers and directories to carry around. If we come next year I won’t bother picking up the bag at all – it’s just a hodge podge of sponsor messages that no one is interested in. Straight into the recycling bin. I just wish they hadn’t bothered to print it in the first place.Sitting in a talkWatching the rest of the conference crowd in a session is fascinating. We’re all geek boys, so everyone has an iPhone and/or a laptop. This constant connection to the digital world has taken over – no one sits and just listens. Everyone is tweeting, blogging, checking which session they’re going to next, checking which sessions they’re missing out on right now.It must be a slightly threatening and interesting measure of engagement. No one was truly paying attention to me talking, but I did get a shed load of tweets!Post match shake downIt sounds from much of Made by Many that we went to quite a varied mix of talks yesterday. Some good, some not so much… However, even the talks that didn’t hit it off became the start of a very interesting debate afterwards. Over a drink of course, this is Austin after all.The “Passion vs Process” debate was particularly interesting. Some of the MxMers who went were a tad scathing:<tweets>The main crux seemed to be that people should focus their careers on their passion. However, no lee way was given for your skill level. Just because you’re passionate about something doesn’t mean that you’re any good at it. (And that certainly isn’t going to bring you happiness!)This turned into an interesting post match talk about what passions some of us had followed and whether they had worked out or not. For example, one of the MxMers once went to a virtually deserted island to write a novel for 6 months. Others had started off their college years being amazing at sports, to a near pro level, but knew their passion, whilst strong, wasn’t enough to get them through to the final yard line.At this point the conversation became a wider discussion about skill. Most fascinating of all was hearing @shanerichmond (first passion: music journalism, not the brilliant technology editor of the Daily Telegraph) talking about writer’s block. For him as a journalist it’s rarely an issue – if you’re writing a news story you have facts to report, if you’re writing an comment piece you have your opinion. You never ever start off with a blank page.As a designer it struck me that at Made by Many we never start off with a blank page either. The way we work and our processes are nearly always intended to lay layer upon layer upon our ideas. That traditional moment of a designer firing up Photoshop for the first time on a project, sitting behind a white screen of empty pixels searching for something to start with rarely happens at MxM. By that stage in the project we have sketches and prototypes to work with. You have the information and service design in your hands – a framework (or in Shane’s case the facts or opinions) to work with.Not so much a revelation, but fascinating to view our process from the perspective of anotherOur home pageThe reaction to our Twitter home page take over has been overwhelmingly positive. Thanks everyone for their feedback and comments. It was really fun working on it and seeing it in use in real time has sparked off lots of ideas about how we could use something similar as our permanent home page once we’re back home. Somehow we need to find a way of showing our social presence and network on the web, whilst combining the conversations around us.
My favourite tweet about our home page?

Ah, our avatars. Always a source of amusement (or horror) when a new set arrive from our amazing illustrator (Paul Davis). I’ve always felt that their style reflects the Made by Many way – sketching and creating things being a big part of who we are and how we work. However, to clarify, in real life none of us have fascinating skin conditions (@saradotdub), badger strips down out forehead (@bobbyc) or bolts sticking out of our neck (@malbonster).
The SXSW experience
After registration at 11 yesterday I spent the entire day with a goodie bag slung over my shoulder, just like many attendee. I think the first thing we all did was sit down and throw stuff away:

After getting rid of so much junk I was still left with a heavy bag of newspapers and directories to carry around. If we come next year I won’t bother picking up the bag at all – it’s just a hodge podge of sponsor messages that no one is interested in. Straight into the recycling bin. I just wish they hadn’t bothered to print it in the first place.
Sitting in a talk
Watching the rest of the conference crowd in a session is fascinating. We’re all geek boys, so everyone has an iPhone and/or a laptop. This constant connection to the digital world has taken over – no one sits and just listens. Everyone is tweeting, blogging, checking which session they’re going to next, checking which sessions they’re missing out on right now.
It must be a slightly threatening and interesting measure of engagement. No one was truly paying attention to me talking, but I did get a shed load of tweets!
Post match shake down
It sounds from much of Made by Many that we went to quite a varied mix of talks yesterday. Some good, some not so much… However, even the talks that didn’t hit it off became the start of a very interesting debate afterwards. Over a drink of course, this is Austin after all.
The “Passion vs Process” debate was particularly interesting. Some of the MxMers who went were a tad scathing:



The main crux seemed to be that people should focus their careers on their passion. However, no lee way was given for your skill level. Just because you’re passionate about something doesn’t mean that you’re any good at it. (And that certainly isn’t going to bring you happiness!)
This turned into an interesting post match talk about what passions some of us had followed and whether they had worked out or not. For example, one of the MxMers once went to a virtually deserted island to write a novel for 6 months. Others had started off their college years being amazing at sports, to a near pro level, but knew their passion, whilst strong, wasn’t enough to get them through to the final yard line.
At this point the conversation became a wider discussion about skill. Most fascinating of all was hearing @shanerichmond (first passion: music journalism, now the brilliant technology editor of the Daily Telegraph) talking about writer’s block. For him as a journalist it’s rarely an issue – if you’re writing a news story you have facts to report, if you’re writing an comment piece you have your opinion. You never ever start off with a blank page.
As a designer it struck me that at Made by Many we never start off with a blank page either. The way we work and our processes are nearly always intended to lay layer upon layer upon our ideas. That traditional moment of a designer firing up Photoshop for the first time on a project, sitting behind a white screen of empty pixels searching for something to start with rarely happens at MxM. By that stage in the project we have sketches and prototypes to work with. You have the information and service design in your hands – a framework (or in Shane’s case the facts or opinions) to work with.
Not so much a revelation, but fascinating to view our process from the perspective of another profession.
-
Battle for Your TV: The Big TV Smackdown at SXSW
I made bad choices for the first two time-slots at SXSW, so I had high hopes for the third, PayTV vs Internet – The Battle For Your TV, featuring Mark Cuban of HDNet and Avner Rosen of Boxee.
It was good to see a debate between two people who genuinely disagree by 180º on how the future of TV will pan out, even if some of the argument was basically dick-swinging.
Cuban believes that the future of TV is basically the same as the present: subscription services over cable or satellite, with a light dash of so-called ‘Interactive TV’. Rosen believes, as I do, that the future of TV is on the web. To be clear: everyone sane accepts that we will continue to have a dedicated large screen in our houses on which we watch video. I just don’t believe that broadcast TV has a future that looks anything like the present, if it has one at all.
-
SXSW countdown: one day!
At long last… tomorrow morning we’re off to Austin!
Stu and Antonica, Made by Many’s de facto cat herders, are limbering up even as we speak to corral the lot of us from Heathrow to Dallas Ft Worth on to Austin. Assuming no one offends Homeland Security on the way in (you know who you are…), we should all be ensconced in our Texan digs by tomorrow evening.
Our departure is big news for our website, as it means our super-dynamic, sex-on-Twittter-toast* SXSW special homepage will be live. We’re kind of excited about this page. As well as all our latest tweets and links to our Twitter accounts, it shows off the latest Made by Many blog post and the most recent addition to our Flickr account. It offers a smooth user experience, too, as everything updates dynamically and in real time.
The page will be live the whole time we’re away, which means you can keep (non-creepy, please) tabs on us and get a sense of what the SXSW experience is like. You’re also heartily invited to @ or DM us with suggestions, feedback, jokes etc while we’re gone — this is, after all, a conversation.
For those who missed the earlier posts on this project, we took this page as an opportunity to open up our creative process and design in public. Here’s the first vision of the page. We followed this with a post on the idea’s evolution before whipping the curtain back for the big reveal.
Thanks very much to everyone who offered feedback on this work — and of course, if you want to do so now, you are more than welcome.
So on that note… have a great week and, um, watch this space!
*not my words but damn do I love ‘em
-
What I’m hoping for from SXSW
I’ve been to loads of conferences over the years. Most of them have left me feeling ‘whelmed’ at best and at most other times frustrated.
I blogged last year about one conference I attended in London last May. There was a general feeling that the speakers offered nothing new, virtually no excitement or insight and most of the talks boiled down to a personal retrospective. That’s fair enough you may say, but the conference was billed as being about the future of the industry.
It felt as if the speakers had just been asked to turn up and speak about anything they wanted. No vetting by the organiser and seemingly very little brief to the speakers.
As such I’ve given up on any conferences this year. Apart, obviously, from the biggy. The one we’re all off to.
-
SXSW countdown: one week
And lo, ready to roll a full week before we take off for Texas, here it is — our Twitter-powered SXSW people-tracker:

For those who haven’t been following the posts and discussions around this project, here’s the story…
Just about all of Made by Many is heading to Austin, Texas for SXSW interactive. Several weeks ago, we decided to build something onto our website to bring our SXSW experience to life for the people who aren’t going to be there with us. We thought this project would also be the perfect occasion to throw the doors open on our creative process and actually share the journey we go through as we work an idea through to a final execution.
This series of posts started with shots of our original approach. We then showed how this idea was refined a few different ways. The third and final instalment in this design journey is above.
The idea for the page is very simple: all of our most recent tweets on one page, updated in real time as it happens.
The design started out as a series of coloured panels, one for each person, laid out on a very regimented grid. However, we all felt that this was a bit strict – it neither reflected our personality nor the event we’re going too.
So we loosened the design up, taking the hand drawn style of our avatars as inspiration. The page is a series of speech bubbles, laid out in a seemingly random and slightly haphazard way. Connected by lines, doodles and graffiti, the speech bubbles change colour with time: the freshest tweets are dark, the stalest white. The page will be darkest when the conference sessions are going on and we’re tweeting non-stop, but completely white in the middle of the night when we’re all sleeping. Except for @malbonster’s bubble. He never stops.
As well as pulling in our tweets, the page also pulls in the latest photo in our Flickr stream, our latest blog posts, even twitpics. You’ll be able to see more tweets from each person by clicking on their avatar or simply going through to their Twitter stream.
The idea for the page is very simple: all of most recent tweets on one page, updated in real time as it happens.The design started out as a series of coloured panels, one for each person, laid out on a very regimented grid. However, we all felt that this was a bit strict – it neither reflected the personality of us or of the event we’re going too.So we loosened the design up, taking the hand drawn style of our avatars as inspiration. The page is a series of speech bubbles, laid out in a seemingly random and slightly haphazard way. Connected by lines, doodles and graffiti, the speech bubbles change colour with time: the freshest tweets are dark, the stalest white.We imagine that the page will be dark red whilst the conference sessions are going on and we’re tweeting virtually non-stop, but completely white in the middle of the night when we’re all sleeping. Except for @malbonster’s bubble. He never stops tweeting.As well as pulling in our tweets, the page also pulls in the latest photo in our Flickr stream, our latest blog post, even twitpics. You can see more tweets from each person by clicking their avatar or simply going through to their twitter stream.We like the sketchy style and the playful execution. We also think the design has some dynamism to it, that it tells a story and carries your eye through that story fairly easily. All in, we think this is really close to who we are.
This whole ‘designing in public’ thing felt a little strange at points (sort of like being naked in front of a lot of people, I reckon) but we got some interesting feedback here and on other blogs, which was cool. And it’s practice for us to be more open in the future — something we are really committed to doing.
Our SXSW special will be live on Made by Many as of Thursday 11 March.


